-
Bug
-
Resolution: Not an Issue
-
P4
-
None
-
1.1, 1.1.6
-
None
-
unknown, x86
-
generic, windows_nt
The behaviour with modal dialogs seems to be to block
all input to all windows in an application. This causes
major problems with a customers help system which needs
to create new dialogs, even during a modal dialog.
>From what I can see in bugtraq this behaviour has
changed back and forth between:
- primary application modal (only the parent frame and its
windows affected)
- full application modal (all windows affected)
They argue (and I think I agree with them) that it
should be the first of the two, although in 1.1.6 it is being changed
to the other. The arguments in favour are:
- help type applications are severely crippled by full application modality
- the documentation seems to imply primary app. modality.
eg. "modal - if true, dialog blocks input to the >>parent<< window when shown"
all input to all windows in an application. This causes
major problems with a customers help system which needs
to create new dialogs, even during a modal dialog.
>From what I can see in bugtraq this behaviour has
changed back and forth between:
- primary application modal (only the parent frame and its
windows affected)
- full application modal (all windows affected)
They argue (and I think I agree with them) that it
should be the first of the two, although in 1.1.6 it is being changed
to the other. The arguments in favour are:
- help type applications are severely crippled by full application modality
- the documentation seems to imply primary app. modality.
eg. "modal - if true, dialog blocks input to the >>parent<< window when shown"
- relates to
-
JDK-4058370 Called modal dialog allows interaction with OTHER top level windows in CDE
-
- Closed
-