Some generated access methods still violate access rules

jvm throws IllegalAccessError exception when executing java class (see source below) using -verify option.

/usr/jdk1.3.1/bin/java -verify QualifiedThisAndSuper_1
Exception in thread "main" java.lang.IllegalAccessError: try to access method QualifiedThisAndSuper_1$AS.n()Ljava/lang/String; from class QualifiedThisAndSuper_1$A
        at QualifiedThisAndSuper_1$A.access$1101(QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java:48)
        at QualifiedThisAndSuper_1$A$B$C.test(QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java:104)
        at QualifiedThisAndSuper_1$A$B.test(QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java:247)
        at QualifiedThisAndSuper_1$A.test(QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java:252)
        at QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.main(QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java:258)

jdk1.3, and solaris jdk1.4.0-beta-b50 have same problem.

Here is log of execution:
<esi@jnana>/set/java/jdk1.4/solaris/bin/javac
QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM warning: ValueGen::do_LoopEnter(...) not
implemented yet
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM warning: ValueGen::do_LoopExit(...) not
implemented yet
<esi@jnana>/set/java/jdk1.4/solaris/bin/java -fullversion
java full version "1.4.0-beta-b50"
<esi@jnana>/set/java/jdk1.4/solaris/bin/java QualifiedThisAndSuper_1
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM warning: ValueGen::do_LoopEnter(...) not
implemented yet
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM warning: ValueGen::do_LoopExit(...) not
implemented yet
foo
bar
baz
foo
bar
baz
foo
bar
baz
foo
bar
baz
foo
bar
baz
foo
bar
baz


----------------------------------------------------
QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java
----------------------------------------------------
/*
 * @test @(#)QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java 1.1 98/07/24
 * @bug 4147520
 * @summary Verify correct implementation of qualified 'this' and 'super'.
 * @author maddox
 *
 * @run compile QualifiedThisAndSuper_1.java
 * @run main QualifiedThisAndSuper_1
 */

public class QualifiedThisAndSuper_1 {

    public class AS {
        String s = "ass";
        private String t = "ast";
        protected String u = "asu";
        String m() { return "asm"; }
        private String n() { return "asn"; }
        protected String o() { return "aso"; }
    }

    public class BS {
        String s = "bss";
        private String t = "bst";
        protected String u = "bsu";
        String m() { return "bsm"; }
        private String n() { return "bsn"; }
        protected String o() { return "bso"; }
    }

    public class CS {
        String s = "css";
        private String t = "cst";
        protected String u = "csu";
        String m() { return "csm"; }
        private String n() { return "csn"; }
        protected String o() { return "cso"; }
    }


    void check(String expr, String result, String expected) {
        if (!result.equals(expected)) {
            throw new Error("Evaluated "+ expr +
                            " : result " + result + ", expected " + expected);
        }
    }

    public class A extends AS {
        A() { super(); }
        String s = "as";
        private String t = "at";
        protected String u = "au";
        String m() { return "am"; }
        private String n() { return "an"; }
        protected String o() { return "ao"; }
        public class B extends BS {
            B() { super(); }
            String s = "bs";
            private String t = "bt";
            protected String u = "bu";
            String m() { return "bm"; }
            private String n() { return "bn"; }
            protected String o() { return "bo"; }
            public class C extends CS {
                C() { super(); }
                String s = "cs";
                private String t = "ct";
                protected String u = "cu";
                String m() { return "cm"; }
                private String n() { return "cn"; }
                protected String o() { return "co"; }
                void test() {

                    check("this.m()", this.m(), "cm");

                    check("A.this.m()", A.this.m(), "am");
                    check("B.this.m()", B.this.m(), "bm");
                    check("C.this.m()", C.this.m(), "cm");

                    check("super.m()", super.m(), "csm");

                    check("A.super.m()", A.super.m(), "asm");
                    check("B.super.m()", B.super.m(), "bsm");
                    check("C.super.m()", C.super.m(), "csm");

                    // should re-use access methods.
                    check("A.super.m()", A.super.m(), "asm");
                    check("B.super.m()", B.super.m(), "bsm");
                    check("C.super.m()", C.super.m(), "csm");

                    //---

                    check("this.n()", this.n(), "cn");

                    check("A.this.n()", A.this.n(), "an");
                    check("B.this.n()", B.this.n(), "bn");
                    check("C.this.n()", C.this.n(), "cn");


                    check("super.n()", super.n(), "csn");



                    check("A.super.n()", A.super.n(), "asn");

                    check("B.super.n()", B.super.n(), "bsn");
                    check("C.super.n()", C.super.n(), "csn");

                    // should re-use access methods.
                    check("A.super.n()", A.super.n(), "asn");
                    check("B.super.n()", B.super.n(), "bsn");
                    check("C.super.n()", C.super.n(), "csn");

                    //---

                    check("this.o()", this.o(), "co");

                    check("A.this.o()", A.this.o(), "ao");
                    check("B.this.o()", B.this.o(), "bo");
                    check("C.this.o()", C.this.o(), "co");

                    check("super.o()", super.o(), "cso");

                    check("A.super.o()", A.super.o(), "aso");
                    check("B.super.o()", B.super.o(), "bso");
                    check("C.super.o()", C.super.o(), "cso");

                    // should re-use access methods.
                    check("A.super.o()", A.super.o(), "aso");
                    check("B.super.o()", B.super.o(), "bso");
                    check("C.super.o()", C.super.o(), "cso");

                    //---
                    
                    check("this.s", this.s, "cs");

                    check("A.this.s", A.this.s, "as");
                    check("B.this.s", B.this.s, "bs");
                    check("C.this.s", C.this.s, "cs");

                    //---

                    check("this.t", this.t, "ct");

                    check("A.this.t", A.this.t, "at");
                    check("B.this.t", B.this.t, "bt");
                    check("C.this.t", C.this.t, "ct");

                    //---
                    
                    check("this.u", this.u, "cu");

                    check("A.this.u", A.this.u, "au");
                    check("B.this.u", B.this.u, "bu");
                    check("C.this.u", C.this.u, "cu");

                    //---
                    
                    check("super.s", super.s, "css");

                    check("A.super.s", A.super.s, "ass");
                    check("B.super.s", B.super.s, "bss");
                    check("C.super.s", C.super.s, "css");

                    //---
                    
                    check("super.t", super.t, "cst");

                    check("A.super.t", A.super.t, "ast");
                    check("B.super.t", B.super.t, "bst");
                    check("C.super.t", C.super.t, "cst");

                    //---
                    
                    check("super.u", super.u, "csu");

                    check("A.super.u", A.super.u, "asu");
                    check("B.super.u", B.super.u, "bsu");
                    check("C.super.u", C.super.u, "csu");

                    //---

                    A.this.s = "foo";
                    System.out.println(A.this.s);
                    check("A.this.s", A.this.s, "foo");
                    B.this.s = "bar";
                    System.out.println(B.this.s);
                    check("B.this.s", B.this.s, "bar");
                    C.this.s = "baz";
                    System.out.println(C.this.s);
                    check("C.this.s", C.this.s, "baz");

                    A.this.t = "foo";
                    System.out.println(A.this.t);
                    check("A.this.t", A.this.t, "foo");
                    B.this.t = "bar";
                    System.out.println(B.this.t);
                    check("B.this.t", B.this.t, "bar");
                    C.this.t = "baz";
                    System.out.println(C.this.t);
                    check("C.this.t", C.this.t, "baz");

                    A.this.u = "foo";
                    System.out.println(A.this.u);
                    check("A.this.u", A.this.u, "foo");
                    B.this.u = "bar";
                    System.out.println(B.this.u);
                    check("B.this.u", B.this.u, "bar");
                    C.this.u = "baz";
                    System.out.println(C.this.u);
                    check("C.this.u", C.this.u, "baz");

                    A.super.s = "foo";
                    System.out.println(A.super.s);
                    check("A.super.s", A.super.s, "foo");
                    B.super.s = "bar";
                    System.out.println(B.super.s);
                    check("B.super.s", B.super.s, "bar");
                    C.super.s = "baz";
                    System.out.println(C.super.s);
                    check("C.super.s", C.super.s, "baz");

                    A.super.t = "foo";
                    System.out.println(A.super.t);
                    check("A.super.t", A.super.t, "foo");
                    B.super.t = "bar";
                    System.out.println(B.super.t);
                    check("B.super.t", B.super.t, "bar");
                    C.super.t = "baz";
                    System.out.println(C.super.t);
                    check("C.super.t", C.super.t, "baz");

                    A.super.u = "foo";
                    System.out.println(A.super.u);
                    check("A.super.u", A.super.u, "foo");
                    B.super.u = "bar";
                    System.out.println(B.super.u);
                    check("B.super.u", B.super.u, "bar");
                    C.super.u = "baz";
                    System.out.println(C.super.u);
                    check("C.super.u", C.super.u, "baz");

                }
            }
            void test() throws Exception {
                C c = new C();
                c.test();
            }
        }
        void test() throws Exception {
            B b = new B();
            b.test();
        }
    }
    
    public static void main(String[] args) throws Exception {
        A a = new QualifiedThisAndSuper_1().new A();
        a.test();
    }
}

==========

Here is a simplified test case:


frog$ cat -n Q1.java
     1 public class Q1 {
     2
     3 public class AS {
     4 private String n() { return "asn"; }
     5 }
     6
     7 void check(String expr, String result, String expected) {
     8 if (!result.equals(expected)) {
     9 throw new Error("Evaluated "+ expr +
    10 " : result " + result + ", expected " + expected);
    11 }
    12 }
    13
    14 public class A extends AS {
    15 public class B {
    16 public class C {
    17 void test() {
    18 check("A.super.n()", A.super.n(), "asn");
    19 }
    20 }
    21 void test() throws Exception {
    22 check("A.super.n()", A.super.n(), "asn");
    23 C c = new C();
    24 c.test();
    25 }
    26 }
    27 void test() throws Exception {
    28 check("A.super.n()", A.super.n(), "asn");
    29 B b = new B();
    30 b.test();
    31 }
    32 }
    33
    34 public static void main(String[] args) throws Exception {
    35 A a = new Q1().new A();
    36 a.test();
    37 }
    38 }
frog$ rm *.class && newjavac Q1.java && newjava Q1
+ /net/frog/gafter/gjc-neal/build/solaris-sparc/bin/java -Xfuture -Xbootclasspath/p:/net/frog/gafter/gjc-neal/gjclasses2 -classpath /net/frog/gafter/gjc-neal/gjclasses2:/net/frog/gafter/gjc-neal/make/tools/javac/gjc.jar:/net/frog/gafter/gjc-neal/make/tools/javac/gjcmain.jar com.sun.tools.javac.Main -classpath . Q1.java
Exception in thread "main" java.lang.IllegalAccessError: try to access method Q1$AS.n()Ljava/lang/String; from class Q1$A
at Q1$A.access$401(Q1.java:14)
at Q1$A.test(Q1.java:28)
at Q1.main(Q1.java:36)
frog$