Name: vpR10072 Date: 11/12/2003



The "Autoboxing and Auto-unboxing support for Java^tm Programming Language"
document reads in JLS 15.25 Conditional Operator ? :

   ...
   # If the second and third operands are of different reference types
     T1 and T2 then the type of the conditional expression is the most
     specific type S such that both T1 and T2 are assignment compatible
     with S.

However, javac reports errors in conditional operator if the second and
third operands are of different reference types so that neither is a
subtype of the other, but there exists the most specific type such that
both operand types are assignment compatible with it.

To reproduce:
-------------

% cat bug.java
-----------------------------------------------cut here
import java.io.PrintStream;


class bugd {
    int a = 1;
}

class buga extends bugd {}

class bugb extends buga {}

public class bug extends buga {

    static final int TTopClass = 0;
    static final int TClass = 1;
    static final int TSubClass = 2;
    static final int TObj = 3;

    static int getType(bugd D) {return TTopClass; }
    static int getType(buga A) {return TClass; }
    static int getType(bugb B) {return TSubClass; }
    static int getType(bug C) {return TSubClass; }
    static int getType(Object O) {return TObj; }

    public static void main(String args[]) {
        System.exit(run(args, System.out) + 95/*STATUS_TEMP*/);
    }

    public static int run(String args[], PrintStream out) {
        bugb c1 = new bugb();
        bug c2 = new bug();

        if ( (getType(true ? c1 : c2) == TClass)
                && (getType(true ? c2 : c1) == TClass)
                && (getType(false ? c1 : c2) == TClass)
                && (getType(false ? c2 : c1) == TClass) )
            return 0/*STATUS_PASSED*/;

        out.println ("FAIL");
        out.println (getType(true ? c1 : c2));
        out.println (getType(true ? c2 : c1));
        out.println (getType(false ? c1 : c2));
        out.println (getType(false ? c2 : c1));
        return 2/*STATUS_FAILED*/;
    }
}
-----------------------------------------------cut here
% java -showversion

java version "1.5.0-beta"
Java(TM) 2 Runtime Environment, Standard Edition (build 1.5.0-beta-b26)
Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM (build 1.5.0-beta-b26, mixed mode)

% javac -source 1.5 bug.java

bug.java:33: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bugb
third operand : bug
        if ( (getType(true ? c1 : c2) == TClass)
                                 ^
bug.java:34: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bug
third operand : bugb
                && (getType(true ? c2 : c1) == TClass)
                                 ^
bug.java:35: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bugb
third operand : bug
                && (getType(false ? c1 : c2) == TClass)
                                  ^
bug.java:36: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bug
third operand : bugb
                && (getType(false ? c2 : c1) == TClass) )
                                  ^
bug.java:40: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bugb
third operand : bug
        out.println (getType(true ? c1 : c2));
                                  ^
bug.java:41: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bug
third operand : bugb
        out.println (getType(true ? c2 : c1));
                                  ^
bug.java:42: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bugb
third operand : bug
        out.println (getType(false ? c1 : c2));
                                   ^
bug.java:43: incompatible types for ?: neither is a subtype of the other
second operand: bug
third operand : bugb
        out.println (getType(false ? c2 : c1));
                                   ^
8 errors

======================================================================