(thread) Thread.currentThread().getStackTrace(); is 10x slower vs getting stacktrace from throwable

It seems like Thread.currentThread().getStackTrace(); is 10x slower,
compared to getting the stacktrace from a throwable. Actually the
overhead is probably due to context switching since all the time in
the first case seems to be SystemTime and not user time.

In my env where I run some stress tests I can max out the 4way Linux
box with 20 client threads when I enable some diagnostic probes within
our code. In this case almost all the CPU is SystemTime and appears to
be due to Thread.currentThread().getStackTrace();

Here is the test case. You will notice that one version is about
10x slower than the other version.


public class Test {

    public Test() {

    }

    public static void main(String[] args) {

long start = System.currentTimeMillis();
for(long i=0; i<100000; i++) {

            StackTraceElement [] stackTrace;

            if (args.length > 0)

stackTrace = new Exception().getStackTrace();

            else

stackTrace = Thread.currentThread().getStackTrace();

}

System.out.println("Total time = " + (System.currentTimeMillis()
- start) + "ms.");

    }
}

I looked into the VM code and here is what I can make of it -

The stack is retrieved by calling vframeStream st((JavaThread*) THREAD);

Both version do this. That is good. The exception version calls this
directly.
The getThreadDumps() does a few "extra" steps that can be more expensive -



1. Get the request into a shared queue

2. Schedule a VM thread to run your command.

3. The scheduled VM thread seems to do some stuff to make sure it's safe
   to get stack trace.

4. Allocates a C++ objects to collect the stack trace. This is much more
   expensive than a Java object. You have to new/delete - acquire mutex
   to do that.

5. Finally calls vframeStream()

6. The VM thread returns the result. And the caller gets the result
   out of the shared queue.
There is a comment in file threadService.cpp that says

// TODO: Optimization if only the current thread or maxDepth = 1