Uploaded image for project: 'JDK'
  1. JDK
  2. JDK-6968622

36.10% osol_1002-143 jbb2005_vm_svr performance regression sparc

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Won't Fix
    • Icon: P2 P2
    • None
    • solaris_11
    • performance
    • sparc
    • solaris_nevada

      12.2% regression in scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT in build osol_1002-143
      scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT :

      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Historical scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT results on oaf223_64
      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Build Result Status Description Related Bugs
      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      osol_1002-143 10.32 RED 12.2% regression
      osol_1002-142 11.75 RED 16% regression
      osol_1002-141 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant6965584
      osol_1002-140 14.34 GREEN unchanged 6957827
      osol_1002-139 14.06 RED 2.4% regression 6953095
      osol_1002-138 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant6950903
      osol_1002-137
      osol_1002-136 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant6942207
      osol_1002-135 ~ YELLOW Baseline data results vary too much (stddev=4.1%)6938683
      osol_1002-134a ~ YELLOW Test data results vary too much (stddev=4.1%)
      osol_1002-134
      osol_1002-133
      osol_1002-132 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant
      osol_1002-131 14.49 GREEN unchanged
      osol_1002-130 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant
      osol_1002-129 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant
      osol_1002-128 GREEN
      osol_1002-127 GREEN
      osol_1002-126 ~ YELLOW Test data results vary too much (stddev=4.1%)
      osol_1002-125 ~ YELLOW Test data results vary too much (stddev=4.2%)
      osol_1002-124 ~ YELLOW Baseline data results vary too much (stddev=4.7%)
      osol_1002-123 ~ YELLOW Test data results vary too much (stddev=4.7%)
      osol_1002-122 ~ YELLOW Comparison not statistically significant
      osol_1002-121 15.16 GREEN 2.8% improvement
      osol_1002-118 14.75 GREEN Not applicable / multimodal
      osol_1002-117 14.37 RED Not applicable / multimodal
      osol_0906-111b2
      osol_0906-111b
      osol_0906-111a
      osol_0906-111 14.52 GREEN Not applicable / multimodal
      osol_0906-110
      osol_0906-109
      osol_0906-108
      osol_0906-107 12.36 RED Not applicable / multimodal
      osol_0906-106a 14.77 First Result

      Using osol_1002-142 as baseline
      24 baselines. Average is 11.75 PctStDevis 13.35%
      Plot_mean: 10.32 , overall change: 12.17 %
      Iteration Result Change Colour
      1 10.117 -13.89 % RED
      2 10.980 -6.54 % RED
      3 10.545 -10.25 % RED
      4 10.069 -14.30 % RED
      5 10.192 -13.25 % RED
      6 10.037 -14.57 % RED
      Number of runs: 6
      With all numbers shown, overall change will be -12.14%
      Previous build:osol_1002-142 11.752 0.02 % YELLOW
      The found results are: 1 YELLOW, 6 RED including the old result
      Std. Deviation as % from Mean is 3.59
      TTest against baseline: 0.0003835350

      Outliers
      =========
      3 high outliers in base
      Can't find the machine in /etc/bootparams.
      Benchmark res_range: 45:-0.5 (not ship)

      Detailed statistical comparison of results is available at:
      http://perfwww.ireland/cgi-bin/detail.cgi?rig=oaf223_64&benchmark=scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT&build=osol_1002-143&base=osol_1002-142&clean=FALSE

      Using s10_74L2a as baseline
      No Baselines
      Plot_mean: 10.32 , overall change: 100.00 %
      Warning: plot_per is 0.00, but overall change is 100.00. Will update later.
      Iteration Result Change Colour
      1 10.117
      2 10.980
      3 10.545
      4 10.069
      5 10.192
      6 10.037
      Number of runs: 6
      With all numbers shown, overall change will be 0.00%
      Previous build:osol_1002-142 11.752
      Std. Deviation as % from Mean is 3.59
      TTest against baseline: 1.0000000000

      Outliers
      =========
      Can't find the machine in /etc/bootparams.
      Benchmark res_range: 45:-0.5 (not ship)

      Detailed statistical comparison of results is available at:
      http://perfwww.ireland/cgi-bin/detail.cgi?rig=oaf223_64&benchmark=scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT&build=osol_1002-143&base=s10_74L2a&clean=FALSE

      http://perfwww.ireland/cgi-bin/publictools/shipII.cgi?&BUILD=snv&BNAMES=scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT&tSysteM=oaf223_64

      The machine is a :Ultra 45 2 x 1600MHz 2048 MB ram
      The same rig is seeing a larger regression in another java metric so I am
      updating the title. I will test the change in java version first.

      Using osol_1002-142 as baseline
      3 baselines. Average is 11465 PctStDevis 0.56%
      Plot_mean: 7326.40 , overall change: 36.10 %
      Iteration Result Change Colour
      1 7321 -36.15 % RED
      10 7366 -35.76 % RED
      2 7315 -36.20 % RED
      3 7261 -36.67 % RED
      4 7315 -36.20 % RED
      5 7325 -36.11 % RED
      6 7361 -35.80 % RED
      7 7346 -35.93 % RED
      8 7290 -36.42 % RED
      9 7364 -35.77 % RED
      Number of runs: 10
      With all numbers shown, overall change will be -36.10%
      Previous build:osol_1002-142 11465 -0.00 % YELLOW
      The found results are: 1 YELLOW, 10 RED including the old result
      Std. Deviation as % from Mean is 0.47
      TTest against baseline: 0.0000225160

      Outliers
      =========
      Can't find the machine in /etc/bootparams.
      Benchmark res_range: 45:-0.5 (not ship)

      Detailed statistical comparison of results is available at:
      http://perfwww.ireland/cgi-bin/detail.cgi?rig=oaf223_64&benchmark=jbb2005_64_vm&build=osol_1002-143&base=osol_1002-142&clean=FALSE
      It looks like the regression is down to the Java version change.

      scimark_server_tuned_large_FFT

      mean change% num stddev% build
      11.75 0.02% 24 osol_1002-142
      10.28 -12.47% 20 3.37 osol_1002-143
      10.79 -8.19% 3 4.15 osol_1002-142-6968622-java-143

      Baseline used: osol_1002-142

      I am rerunning

      osol_1002-142-6968622-java-143 here is osol_1002-143 with 'runtime/java'
      from osol_1002-143.

      osol_1002-142 version:
      java version "1.6.0_18"
      Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.6.0_18-b07)
      Java HotSpot(TM) Server VM (build 16.0-b13, mixed mode)

      osol_1002-143 version:
      java version "1.6.0_21"
      Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.6.0_21-b06)
      Java HotSpot(TM) Server VM (build 17.0-b16, mixed mode)
      The jb2005 regression also has java as it's root cause:

      mean change% num stddev% build (results)
      15227.00 0.00% 3 osol_1002-142 (15242 15145 15294)
      9910.90 -34.91% 10 0.61 osol_1002-143 (9811 9923 9951 9886 9935 9851 9914 9854 10004 9980)
      9995.00 -34.36% 1 osol_1002-142-6968622-java-143-6968622-rerun (9995)

      Baseline used: osol_1002-142

      Here are the rig details:

      The rig seeing this regression is:
      Ultra 45:oaf223_64:2 x 1600MHz:2048 MB:XVR-100

      The regession was in jbb2005_vm_svr which can be found:
      http://perfwww.ireland/Benchmarks/Java/jbb05.tar.gz

      Explorer:
      http://perfwww.ireland/cgi-bin/internaltools/machineStats.cgi?osol_1002-143:oaf223_64

      Statis before regression:
      http://perfwww.ireland/Results9/osol_1002-142.oaf223_64/jbb2005_vm_svr/3/statit.bin.txt
      http://perfwww.ireland/Results9/osol_1002-142.oaf223_64/jbb2005_vm_svr/2/statit.bin.txt
      http://perfwww.ireland/Results9/osol_1002-142.oaf223_64/jbb2005_vm_svr/1/statit.bin.txt

      Statits after regression:
      http://perfwww.ireland/Results9/osol_1002-142-6968622-java-143-6968622-rerun.oaf223_64/jbb2005_vm_svr/1/statit.bin.txt

            Unassigned Unassigned
            gmurdoch Greg Murdoch (Inactive)
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            0 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              Imported:
              Indexed: