The motivation is timeouts like JDK-8267348. Note that we are spending a significant amount of time getting pc = os::current_frame() during oop registration.

As far as I understand from the Hotspot code, that is only to print the PC when the unhandled oops detector fails _itself_:

    // If an entry is on the unhandled oop list but isn't on the stack
    // anymore, it must not have gotten unregistered properly and it's a bug
    // in the unhandled oop generator.

Since that condition must be rare, we can save considerable time not taking "pc" on every oop registration, with a minor (?) downside that we would not get the PC when unhandled oops detector is broken.

Motivational example is the test that enters the registrator path very often:

$ time CONF=linux-x86_64-server-fastdebug make run-test TEST=gc/epsilon/TestClasses.java TEST_VM_OPTS="-XX:+CheckUnhandledOops"

Before:

real 6m7.516s
user 6m38.876s
sys 0m4.566s

After:

real 2m33.344s
user 3m4.788s
sys 0m4.351s

Tier1 also improves significantly:

$ time CONF=linux-x86_64-server-fastdebug make run-test TEST=tier1 TEST_VM_OPTS="-XX:+CheckUnhandledOops"

Before:

real 60m43.022s
user 1546m54.452s
sys 45m0.769s

After:

real 42m59.204s
user 1347m41.339s
sys 50m43.837s

For the reference, the baseline without CheckUnhandledOops enabled:

$ time CONF=linux-x86_64-server-fastdebug make run-test TEST=tier1

real 32m57.509s
user 1230m5.149s
sys 54m23.135s

In other words, this cuts out about 2/3 of CheckUnhandledOops overhead.