DumpInline option is available in production build but ReplayInline is ifdef-ed out in the product build:

---
#ifndef PRODUCT
  set_parsed_irreducible_loop(false);

  if (directive->ReplayInlineOption) {
    _replay_inline_data = ciReplay::load_inline_data(method(), entry_bci(), ci_env->comp_level());
  }
#endif
---

If DumpInline is enabled in product builds, so should the ReplayInline be.